Skip to content


Colonial Insurance Agency was founded over 40 years ago by Jack Babnew. The agency started in a single room and has steadily grown over the years to represent some of the largest and most well known Insurance companies in the world. As a family owned agency it is extremely important that we provide personal contact with our clients in order to make sure that each business has the correct coverage and also address year to year changes in your business. As a Workers Compensation specialist our agency will make sure that your business will receive the maximum allowable discounts based on each individual business qualifications.

Book a Consultation

Mon Tue Wed Thu Fri

We look forward to shopping the marketplace for your insurance needs:

Business Owners Policy · Workers Compensation · Business · Auto · Umbrella

Let our agents give your business the personal attention that it deserves.

Featured Carriers

What Our Clients Say

I have been working with Al Bender at Colonial Insurance Agency for some time now, and he never ceases to amaze me. I am in the process of opening up my own pharmacy, and Mr. Bender helped me obtain the best coverage for my store. He is very honest, highly knowledgeable about pharmacies. able to multi-task, has a very pleasant demeanor, and is like Superman when you are pressed for time. His staff is amazing as well (Cathi). I highly recommend Al Bender for all your insurance needs. Trust me… you will not be disappointed!

I started working with Al bender for my new infusion pharmacy and I like his work and I did my second retail pharmacy with him. Colonial Insurance is only company in NJ do infusion pharmacy insurance and retail pharmacy insurance with all the new requirements for enrolling in PBMS,

I have very good and professional experience with Al Bender, he is professional, friendly, and very helpful in advising on insurance policies with the new requirements. He did all my insurance in timely and well-organized way. I highly recommend him and Colonial Insurance company.

Book a Consultation

Mon Tue Wed Thu Fri